Subscribe to Naomi's blog and receive a notification every time Naomi posts a new article.Click to Subscribe

GAZA WAR DIARY: 4 SEPTEMBAR 2024

Do you remember a day when the weather was so foul that you couldn’t go outside? You couldn’t even look outside because there was a howling wind, and an icy brutal rain that landed like icicles, piercing coats and hats, and freezing toes? So you stayed indoors. Maybe you lit up the fireplace, turned up the heat, watched an old movie you loved. Had a hot cocoa, and just tried to endure until the day was over and the weather changed.

That’s how I feel now. I go to the pool. Meet my friends for our lively aerobics class. My garden is blooming. The sea is blue and calm. But the minute I turn on the news, read a newspaper, the unbearable nightmare of our current situation bangs against the windows of my shelter, demanding attention. It’s almost unbearable.

I open up Ynet, whose publisher is behind so much of the causeless hatred and venom vented against our less than perfect, but very, very brave Prime Minister, and am bombarded by articles in which Israel’s military establishment broadcasts weakness: Halevi hints we can leave Philadephi and come back? And how many soldiers’ lives is that going to cost? And are those lives less valuable than the hostages? I read about the thousands of Israelis rioting in the streets because they have nothing to contribute, and nothing intelligent to say, so why not destroy, undermine all that is heroic, good, unselfish, noble by those who are fighting the last battle of this terrible war?

I peek at what’s going on in the White House, the collapse and betrayal by a corrupt, weak and stupid administration, who wants it both ways: Condemning the barbarians who killed hostages – some of them American –  while condemning in the same breath the Israeli leader who is trying so hard to protect 9 million Israelis from endless repetitions of the October 7 massacre by the barbarians across the border fence. Hamas are still there, still armed, thousands of them. They are still able to fight, still have the initiative.

Our enemies are so numerous. All the “peace agreements” were broken. Egypt allowed Gaza to build tunnels and arm terrorists. The Oslo Accords blew up in our face as we now try to dig out from under the terror infrastructure in the West Bank under Mahmoud Abbas.

The “Disengagement” that then Prime Minister Ehud Olmert told me to my face was going to “save soldiers’ lives?” Another catastrophic mistake. And all the Left wing, Peace-Now, Four Mothers (who got us out of Lebanon and let Hezbollah take over) where are they now? Why, demonstrating in the streets to force us into another catastrophic mistake for which they will take no responsibility. Ever.

Listen to this as an example. Today Liat Atzili, who was abducted to Gaza and released after 54 days in captivity through our Prime Minister and the IDF, was invited to speak by Peres’s daughter at a memorial ceremony at Har Herzl at the eighth anniversary of the death of Shimon Peres – another architect of Israeli disaster –  and had the nerve to say: “Eight years have passed since you left us, Mr. Peres, and it feels like ages! Netanyahu succeeded in erasing the dream of peace, putting aside hope, dividing the people and uniting all our enemies against us.”

Such historical revisionism! Apparently being kidnapped by our “peace partners” and having her husband slaughtered has not dimmed her enthusiasm for Mr. Peres’s delusional outlook that saw so many Israelis blown up on buses and in their hotels by Yasir Arafat’s “sacrifices for peace.” Really. At times, I despair.

What did FDR say about the Nazis? “You can’t tame a tiger by petting him…There is only one way to have peace with the Nazis – one of you has to surrender.” And that is exactly what people like Liat Atzili want us to do. Surrender to Hamas.

Do we want that kind of peace with Hamas, the peace of our surrender? The end our country?

I certainly do not. I know that the great majority of Israelis feel the same. We cannot turn back. We must keep going because to stop now would be to betray all those who have been brutally murdered, or laid down their lives with courage to prevent just such an outcome. People say: “But what if it was your child being held hostage? Your father? Your husband, your brother?”

Do you know that there are parents of hostages who have said “My child would not want a single murderer released for his sake”? Like Tzvika Mor, founder of Tikva Forum, the hostage family group opposed to negotiations with Hamas terrorists: “It’s not just about my personal suffering as Eitan’s father; it’s about the nation as a whole,” Mor said in December. “I can’t let my personal hurt take priority over collective interests. Letting terrorists go free endangers Jewish lives. And Eitan wouldn’t want that.”

We don’t hear those voices, because political interests that want to take down Netanyahu drown them out with their shouting in our streets. Now all we hear are the voices who would sacrifice us all, like the parents of Gilad Shalit once did, to free their child. They are single-minded and directed at only one outcome, and anyone who disagrees is shamed into silence.

Can we criticize them? Dare we criticize them? Probably not. To be selfish and single-minded is what is expected. And yet, thousands upon thousands of Israelis have left their wives and children, and gone into the maelstrom to kill our murderers in Gaza, Lebanon, and the West Bank. They have flown the planes that destroyed the leaders of Hamas all over the world. What about them? What about their sacrifice, their families, their lives?

Still, I go to sleep with hope in my heart, and each morning I awake, hoping that God has taken pity on us and the weather has finally, finally changed.


Spread the word. Share this post!

13 comments on “GAZA WAR DIARY: 4 SEPTEMBAR 2024”

  1. Andy

    May I draw people’s attention to the activities of the Barbary Corsairs, who were privateers operating on behalf of the Islamic Barbary States of North Africa. These privateers raided both boats and coastline towns for over 300 years, abducting and enslaving over a million “infidels.”

    Some of these “infidel” slaves were worked to death by their Islamic masters. Some were ransomed back to their homeland for exorbitant sums of money.

    The more the home countries paid out these ransoms, and signed “treaties” with these brutes, the more they did it. This went on for hundreds of years, with no end in sight.

    The only thing these barbarians understood was force. For example, Lord Exmouth led an Anglo-Dutch fleet to Algiers in 1816, and after being on the receiving end of a nine-hour naval bombardment, the dey of Algiers agreed to hand over all of his slaves, and to hand back ransoms previously paid.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombardment_of_Algiers_(1816)

    There are times when diplomacy and negotiation works, no doubt. But there are times when you are dealing with people who will only recognise power. As Winston Churchill said during WW2, there was no point trying to negotiate with the original Nazis, all that the Allies could do was defeat them using (as Churchill said) “the proper application of overwhelming force.”

  2. Joy Gordon-Fialkov

    Thank you Naomi -a brilliant assessment of this sad and agonizing situation.
    These brave young soldiers risking their lives daily during these senseless demonstrations -which only appease Hamas and the Biden/Harris government.
    I pray for a united society .
    May Hashem keep you and yours safe.

  3. Beverly Lyons

    Brilliant as always. Your article included many interesting f our previous blunders, but not the Schalit deal which created the motivation for the kidnapping . But unfortunately people simply refuse to admit that they are wrong and so because they hate Netanyahu for his willingness to agree to almost anything to stay in power, they refuse to see that his leadership in this war has been very strong. Instead they choose to listen to the army leadership who claim that we can leave Philadelphi and retake it if we need ( with the blood of our sons). Not learning the lesson of the withdrawal from southern Lebanon – where we relied on UNIFIL. These army leaders who betrayed us and have not taken any responsibility for the Oct. 7. We need to get rid of Hakevi and his henchmen so that we can win this war and speak with one voice.

  4. Leah Rabi

    The loudest voices are certainly not the majority of voices.. We cannot allow that narrative to destroy our resolve. I pray the Netanyahu hears the majority and not the echo of the misguided people on the streets. Israel is all we have…May Hashem Always give you the strength to drown out the fridge left…

  5. Ellen Calderon (Solomon)

    Here in south Florida we pray for you to all be safe including my grandchildren and their families who are now living in Jerusalem where they feel safer

  6. Eliezer

    Naomi – you have hit the nail on its head- it appears the people are brain dead whilst the rest of the Western world rubs their hands with glee at the though of another Holocaust.
    Even our brothers in the Diaspora, with few dedicated exceptions, remain silent, just as their forbearers did in the 1930’s

    • Thomas

      Your thoughts resonate with me. Your diagnosis in a nutshell is very insightful, just.

  7. Ronald Fadel MD

    I have to wonder with great despair why this woman’s voice is lost in a wilderness of idiocy….idiots who embrace their self-imposed catastrophy and yearn to be loved by those who would destroy them. Those same fools who forget history. Small example…The Lebanese conveniently forget that prior to the winning of WW I by the British/French alliance, Lebanon was not a county. It was part of Syria and carved out as a nation after the war by WINNER MANDATE. So too is Israel….Those who fail to see this are doomed to have their front door kicked in by conquering Moslems ….sleep will fools….

    • Laurie

      I think if we do a ceasefire, return Philadelphi corridor and basically give victory to hamass, we have spat in the faces of the soldiers who have lost their lives defending us. What is proven is that those we THOUGHT were our friends are not….we can only rely on ourselves. And the hostage demonstrations are doing hamass’s job for them…..!!!! Shame on us. For the families of hostages it must be beyond horrenduous but if we give in, the murderers will be back…..possibly quite soon. Thank you Naomi for your articles, telling us like it is. Laurie

  8. golda

    I pity Gilad Shalit. He has to live for the rest of his life with the knowledge that his release is responsible for all the hostages taken Oct. 7, dead and alive.
    His release is responsible for all the brave IDF soldiers dead and wounded, and all the Israelis killed, maimed, raped, tortured, and whose bodies have been desecrated.
    Israel instead of feeding, clothing, and affording a university education to all terrorists, must kill all in their prisons.
    There should been no one to trade, and their bodies fed to pigs.

    • Eliezer

      Exactly – don’t for get his father was a PR man just like Hersh’s father

    • Thomas

      The antisemitic Red Cross never tried to contact Israeli captives at Gaza but was worried that the Nubka terrorists in Israeli prisons get their visit to sign some documents that would enable the PA to Pay for Slay. Disgusting antisemites. During WW2 also, antisemites.

Comments are closed.

Discover more from Naomi Ragen נעמי רגן

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading