Subscribe to Naomi's blog and receive a notification every time Naomi posts a new article.Click to Subscribe

GAZA WAR DIARY: 22 AUGUST 2024

On Wednesday, the head of the IDF’s Military Intelligence Directorate, Major General Aharon Haliva, stepped down, taking responsibilty for the intelligence failure that resulted in the death of over a thousand Israelis and the kidnapping of hundreds.

“On that Saturday we did not fulfill the most important mission which we are tasked with, providing a warning for war,” he said during a handover ceremony at the Glilot Base near Herzliya, which houses some of the directorate’s units. “The responsibility for the failures of the Military Intelligence Directorate is on me,” Haliva said. But at the same time, he hinted it’s not so simple, and called for establishing a state commission of inquiry into “all aspects that led to war, so that what happened to us will not happen ever again.”

Journalist Amit Segal was not impressed: “Whoever really believes himself responsible for a failure that [in his own words] ‘will haunt him until the day [he] dies’ doesn’t arrange a huge send-off for himself with 1,500 participants. He simply spends time in his office with his computer and a few colleagues and that’s it.” Segal called him: “The Eli Zeira of our time.” Zeira was the head of Military Intelligence found to be responsible for the disaster of the Yom Kippur war.

Taking over the role is Major General Shlomi Binder, the former commander of the IDF’s Operations Division, and a controversial choice since he too is tainted with the intelligence failures of October 7. “Where we failed, we will need to investigate and improve; where we made mistakes we will learn and change; where fractures were opened, however big they are, we will insist on fixing and repent,” Binder said.“The Israeli people have no other country, the State of Israel doesn’t have another IDF, and the IDF doesn’t have another Intelligence Directorate.” True.

Chief of Staff Herzi Halevi was generous to Haliva, basically saying he had done many impressive things despite this one failure. It was a those-who-don’t-go into-the-kitchen-never-break-eggs defense, which leaves me unmoved.

Haliva had the information that would have saved thousands of lives and instead of doing something with it, he went to sleep October 6 and let us wake up to the horror of October 7. He will not forgive himself. But neither will any of us forgive him.

The forensic analyses of the corpses of Israeli hostages Haim Peri, Yagev Buchshtab, Avraham Munder, Yoram Metzger, Nadav Popplewell, and Alexander Dancyg show all were murdered in cold blood. Found beneath Khan Younis, the bodies are riddled with bullets, perhaps because their captors feared a rescue attempt which might free them. It is so sickening. Every time I see some pink-haired girl in a keffiyeh with a Hamas headband, I want to bash her head in. Good thing I am far away from such people.

The war in the north is escalating as the war in Gaza winds down. Sinwar has added to the clauses in the “negotiations” that he be allowed to walk free. He’s willing, he says, to leave the rule of Gaza in the hands of some other entity, as long as he can rebuild his terror organization, buy more weapons and continue his “resistance.” This is his negotiating stance. He wants the IDF to disappear. You heard me. Is it any wonder no progress is being made? He is basically saying, “you can have the few hostages still alive, and many more who are dead, if you let us prepare for the next October 7.”

Ah, I don’t think so. We will rescue the hostages ourselves, thank you very much. The bodies recently found would not have been returned for months within the framework of the current negotiations anyway.

Hezbollah is raining rockets down on civilians, hitting a house in Katzrin and one in another Jewish village. Miraculously, only one person was moderately injured, and the second house, where a father, mother and child were in residence when the rocket hit, no one at all. It’s a miracle. The war in the north will start soon, I have no doubt.

One real advantage the Israel has over Hezbollah are the Lebanese people, the majority of whom hate Hezbollah. Many have been happy to share valuable intelligence with Israel to help in the war. Many believe that if Israel shows it is serious about defeating Hezbollah, the Lebanese people will arise and participate in helping to get the job done.

Israel’s enemies on her other borders, like the terrorist “refugee camp” Tulkarem, are absolutely part of this war. The IDF just spent 14 hours in Tulkarem, blasting away at terrorists, destroying bomb factories, confiscating weapons, and killing four terrorists. These are the people poised to invade Kfar Saba, Herzliya and Tel Aviv, “settlements in the Gush Dan Envelope.” Which is to say, all of Israel in on a border with blood thirsty, depraved terrorists, and the fight is to the death. Literally.

We cannot allow ourselves to feel overwhelmed or discouraged. I believe we are making enormous progress and that our God is with us.

When I watch the delusional idiots demonstrating in Chicago, burning American and Israeli flags, nourished by lies and ignorance and baseless hatred, I can only hope that the American people will be spared the kind of wake-up call we in Israel faced this year. I hope that Americans are wise enough to vote out the current sickening regime in the White House. The Obamas’ ugly handprints are all over this attempt to replace one corrupt leader with another even more unworthy (if that’s even possible…) candidate Kamala Harris, an antisemite and a Communist. Her running mate is a politician with negative accomplishments, a liar, and a man so woke he put Tampax in boys’ bathrooms.

America can’t do worse than these two.


Spread the word. Share this post!

25 comments on “GAZA WAR DIARY: 22 AUGUST 2024”

  1. Thomas

    Your narrative is ahistorical, divorced from facts. Its a reprise of leftist lies about Trump. Brainwashed.

  2. Sara

    Thank you so much Naomi for your coverage. Reading the comments, it is so clear to me how divided our world has become, not only divided, but people are so attached to their perspective and convictions that calm exchange of opinion is no longer an option. I personally am appalled by the manipulative stance of Biden/Harris and crazy idiot. To put forth headlines like Caesefire Agreement as a manipulative tactic for the DNC… when there was never an agreement on the table- it was simply their way to manipulate audience in their favour. Can it not be obvious by now that there is NO NEGOTIATING with terrorists? While I feel so deeply for the parents and relatives of the hostages, psychological warfare has been the biggest game of hamas from the start and pretty much all they have left. RE TRump…Initially I disliked him immensely but seeng the antics of Harris and her hypocritical mob of socialists/marxists (While Kamal wears a 60K$ necklace and the Obamas own 3 homes but none of them held any other position other than government ones) and followers who can not see clearly…well I am completely swayed to the right.. Also as I’ve researched his time in power, I agree, Trump knows how to run an economy and has no time for terrorist BS. Also…having seen how the media can completely twist a narrative, my thoughts explore the possibility that the left media has completely twisted much of the script on the Trump admin. I am on board with those who feel anyone who votes for this extreme left regime needs to have their head examined. It’s a tough and strange time we are living in. I am grateful for you Naomi as you report from a stance that makes complete sense to me. Am Chai Yisrael.

  3. Vivian Davis

    You are right on, G-D bless Israel. I am not Jewish but read your column every day. Many Americans have your back. Please stay strong.

  4. Liz Kittredge

    Naomi—-What happened today? All the self-hating brainwashed got together to try to take over your comment section? Their ignorance and lack of knowing any history is appalling, scary, dangerous.
    My father was smart enough to leave Germany in 1935. The rest of the family including almost 100 cousins were MURDERED by the Nazis. The anti-Semitism here is worse than Germany in the 1930’s. WAKE UP …..woke people. Terrorists’ charter says death to Israel. Without Israel there will be another Holocaust.

  5. Stephen Stein

    Kamala, Trump or whatever. The West is circling the drain, bereft of leadership anywhere. Grist for our many enemies who will probably capitalize on Western dysfunction. There will regional wars or worse. Hashem, Allah, Jesus or whatever god(s) one believes in will not save us. You will not find solace in the annals of history which is replete with greed, destruction and death. It is the way of our species.

  6. Guy

    In 193 2 Germany had democratic elections. Jews, “Half Jews” and “Quarter Jews”
    voted for Hitler.
    In 2008, 2012, Jews voted for our friend Obama.
    In 2020 Jews voted for Biden
    and in 2024 many “Jews” will vote for Kamala Harris.
    Jews should have their head examined for voting for those anti-semites
    and anti-Israel.
    You should all read the book “Why are Jews Liberals” By Norman Podhoretz

  7. Ellen Calderon

    My family in Israel have left their northern homes and are staying in Jerusalem, Hashem has always tried to help the Jews that’s why we’re still here after thousands of years others tried to kill us, stay safe.

  8. Linda

    Love your Gaza War Diary – I look forward to reading it everyday. And you are spot on about the Obamas, the current administration and Harris and Walz. I wish the media here in America would report the facts so people would know the truth, but they won’t. Know that many of us in the U.S. are on Israel’s side and pray for you daily. Thank you for speaking truth.

  9. Ronald Fadel MD

    American Jews who favor Harris and the democrats are sadly empty headed and have complete ignorance of the Islamic threat to our world….stone age cave dwelling culture rising up where Hitler left off….the sad sad truth is the Ashkanazi descendants empathize and understand the Holocaust but not the suffering of those who lived under the heel of Islam.

  10. Linda

    I really appreciate your blog. Although I don’t agree with everything you write you raise important perspectives and provide facts that I as an American Jew
    appreciate.

    Donald Trump presents a real and present danger to America. I do appreciate his hard line stance on Iran and the Abraham accords. His current stance on Israel does not seem to be different than Joe Biden’s or Kamala Harris’. I do that think either of them are anti-semites. I share your concerns about how the Obahma White House dealt with Irat,

    I am very concerned that Americans are not getting the full picture of what is going on in Israel. Largely because our press and most of our political leaders do not cover the attack of Israel by Hezbollah on October 8, 2023 (and the continuing daily barrage} or the displacement of 100,000 Israelis in the North and South. They do not cover the extraordinary efforts the IDF has taken to protect Gaza civilians, the number of Gaza civilians who took part in October 7th or the huge amount of humanitarian aid provided to Gaza while none is provide to Israelis. Both Trump and Harris support a two state solution which seems like a pipe dream as long as Arabs, who refer to themselves as Palestinians, are committed to the destruction of Israel.
    at
    As to the intelligence lapse by Israeli intelligence, the US had a similar lapse that resulted in September 11, 2001. I don’t recall any US intelligence officials stepping down.

  11. Audrey

    Despite the comments of two people above, I love your daily missives( except Shabbat). As an Israeli- Canadian I stand with you and your statements and opinions 100%. I watch a lot of news here and am following the American elections closely. Given Harris’ extremely Left viewpoints and the “importing” of ten million illegal immigrants, completely unvetted, I pray the Republicans win. Western civilization is at stake. HaShem bless you and all Am Yisrael.

  12. Thomas

    Your narrative is ahistorical, divorced from facts. Its a reprise of leftist lies about Trump. Brainwashed.

  13. Rabbi Mikki Mendelsohn

    I used to be able to read your things but I find that you do not have any nuanced understanding of what is really happening in America. Trump lies, cheats, steals is a covicted felon by a jury of his peers, treats people badly, especially women and veterans and has never once shown empathy for anyone. I’ll admit that Republicans of old used to be pro-Israel but so are Democrats. The Maga Republicans have a plan (google “project 2025” it is 900 pages) which lays out a plan to do away with most of the protections the government has for its people. The very leftist Democrats, which make up a small portion of the party, are Gaza loving and don’t even know where Gaza is. But Harris is married to a Jew and has always had serious Jewish support. My civil and humanitarian rights will not be taken away. She is pro-abortion and pro LGBTQ rights which Republicans will repudiate.

    • Thomas

      Your narrative is ahistorical, divorced from facts. Its a reprise of leftist lies about Trump. Brainwashed.

      • Liz Rome

        Linda—You seem to have some of the important facts about the truth of what is happening in Israel–many thanks to Naomi for them. But you are uninformed about some of the most important ones. First: Trump did even more than the incredibly great Abraham Accords. Moving the US embassy to Jerusalem was both concrete and symbolic. Recognizing the Golan Heights as a permanent part of Israel–equally important for defense. I’ve been there–they are essential for protection.
        Trump no different than Harris? You can’t be serious. She shrieks about Gaza’s civilian casualties but NEVER a work about Ukrainians. That’s anti-Semitism. She goes along with Biden not delivering **Congress approved weapons.
        Totally WRONG about 2-state “solution”. There already was one–it’s called Gaza -for the past 20 years. Then October 7 happened!
        What do you say about “the river to the sea” chants? Hamas and other terrorists’ charters say: death to Israel-death to America.
        Kamala trying to pander votes from the radicals here is dangerous and shows she has NO principles/backbone…will do anything to get elected. Especially flip-flop. SO HOW can we Jewish people vote for her? Not me!

    • Margol

      Yes,married to a Jew, whose daughter marches with and supports the demonstrators!
      Ignorant to the core !
      She should maybe take a trip to Iran.
      She is now an adult, so no hands of the children of people in the news.

      • Liz Rome

        Margol–Today must be the day of brainwashed Democrats trying to push lies. “daughter marches with demonstrators”? WHEN? WHERE? YOU are the ignorant!

    • Liz Rome

      Mikki (how are you a rabbi?)– obviously you are a self-hating Jewish person. You are supporting your suicide–and Israel’s by backing the violent, virulent, anti-Semitic brainwashed demonstrators and other Democrats.

    • Margo

      ” Mikki”, I doubt very much you read all “900” pages, because then you would know what you are talking about, not guessing.

  14. Sherrie Sicam

    Better economy, no wars, Jerusalem acknowledged as the capital of Israel, the Golan Heights recognized as part of Israel, Iran ‘s nuclear program deterred, establishment of
    the Abraham accords. All accomplished under President Trump. Sue, I am sorry that you have been brainwashed.

  15. Sue Freedland

    America can do worse if it elects Donald Trump . Harris is not an anitisemite in any way . I no longer want your emails nor will I read any more of your books.

Comments are closed.

Discover more from Naomi Ragen נעמי רגן

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading