Subscribe to Naomi's blog and receive a notification every time Naomi posts a new article.Click to Subscribe

Egged and the Taliban

I can’t remember the last time I took a bus in Jerusalem.

But Monday morning, in the throes of a new exercise regimen, I found myself walking down Strauss Street and, as luck would have it, the number 40 bus stopped right in front of me. It’s the bus with the shortest route to my home in Ramot, a neighborhood divided between secular, modern Orthodox, and haredi inhabitants.

The bus was empty when I got on. Completely empty. So I paid my fare, got my receipt, and chose a single seat near the front.

I was happily immersed in an article about Yaddo in Vanity Fair when I was interrupted by an angry haredi man who announced that I needed to move to the back of the bus. I looked up at him, astonished, feeling a flash of what Blacks must have felt in Alabama in 1950.

Now, in the past, I have been willing to accommodate ultra-Orthodox men on public buses. If the buses are crowded, I don’t mind moving next to another woman to free up two seats for such men.
But here I was, sitting alone in a one-seater.

Very calmly, and politely I think, I told him that this was a public bus and I would sit where I liked. He didn’t have to sit next to me, and he didn’t have to look at me.

He shuffled off quietly, taking one of the many, many available seats. And that, I thought, was that.

It wasn’t. A few stops later, another haredi man – this time with the build of a Sumo wrestler – aggressively planted his two feet squarely in front of my seat and, in a loud and abusive tone and in no uncertain terms, demanded that I move to the back of the bus.

At this point, annoyance gave way to Martin Luther King-like outrage. I looked up into his puffy white face set in nasty and determined lines and said, clearly: “When you show me where in the Shulhan Aruch [Code of Jewish Law] it says I can’t sit in this seat, I will move.

“Until then,” I suggested helpfully, “get out of my face.”

He didn’t take my suggestion but continued to rant and rave. I am absolutely confident that only the prohibitions against touching a woman (that actually are in the Shulchan Aruch) saved me from being bodily hauled from my seat.

Eventually, realizing he’d used up whatever male powers he thought he possessed to whip me into obedience, he moved away, muttering loudly, finally squeezing his ample frame into one of the many available seats in the self-proclaimed “men’s section.”

The entire ride, I continued to be the target of intermittent abuse until he finally got off, not forgetting to hurl a final nasty farewell.

“You’re a great tzaddik,” I retorted, not looking up.

ALL THIS TIME, the bus driver said nothing, even though it was clear to him what was happening. As my stop neared, I glanced at the women dutifully crowded into the back. Many of them were engrossed in reciting Psalms. I suppose that’s one solution.

However, once I reached home I decided to call Egged’s public complaint department in Jerusalem. Does Egged, which enjoys government subsidies and owns the exclusive franchise to run public transportation in the nation’s capital, have a policy that women must sit on the back of the bus?

And if they do, why not put a sign on buses informing innocent female passengers of that fact, allowing them to decide whether or not to board? And if there is no such policy, how is it that the driver gave me no protection whatsoever from nonstop harassment during the entire ride?

This is what I was told: “The number 40 bus is a public bus and passengers may sit anywhere they choose. However, on those lines (and number 40 is one) on which 95 percent of the passengers are haredim, we allow the passengers to decide how they want to divide the seating. Egged doesn’t interfere.”

That is certainly true. There was no interference. Even when a passenger was harassed, abused, insulted and intimidated for having the temerity to be a woman who doesn’t want to sit in the back of the bus.

I have a suggestion for Egged. Either put a sign in the front of bus 40 telling women they should go to the back of the bus, or put up one informing all passengers that they are now boarding public transportation, and that if their piety doesn’t allow them to see a woman sitting in the front of a bus, they should take a taxi.

And if not, perhaps the Israeli government should allow the creation of another bus company to fulfill the needs of public transportation in Jerusalem, one that will protect its female passengers from the Jewish Taliban?

Spread the word. Share this post!

12 comments on “Egged and the Taliban”

  1. washington heights dentist

    Thanks for ones marvelous posting! I genuinely
    enjoyed reading it, you happen to be a great author.
    I will ensure that I bookmark your blog and may come back at some point.
    I want to encourage you continue your great posts, have a nice day!

  2. Miami Gardens Traffic school

    I’m excited to find this web site. I want to to thank you for your time for this
    fantastic read!! I definitely really liked every little bit of it and I have you book marked to see
    new stuff in your web site.

  3. Pingback: A Sign of Change? Police Fight Kotel Bus Segregation Attempt « Jacob's Bones

  4. Pingback: That US Travel Advisory Has Been Around for a Long Time « Jacob's Bones

  5. M. Laszlo

    Good for you for standing up to these haredi taliban guys! Such discrimination is wrong, as wrong as when blacks in north america were placed into such positions. Religion or no religion, we are all equal and there is no justification for such archaic and primitive “rules”

  6. rg

    You’re a force to be reckened with…..that being said, where is the simple courtesy and respect for one another? And more importantly, to harass and/or embarass an individual? I think not! His individual actions speaks for the kind of person he is….does he treat his Mother, Wife and Sister in the same manner????

  7. michael redhill

    This story astonishes me. That men(?) in this day and age can behave like this (like the taliban) can go unpunished…… Words fail me.

  8. michael redhill

    This astonishes me!! Next they will require women to be accompanied by a male relative,
    And the bus driver?? And the other people on the bus?? I always thought Israel to be a caring and protective society. This is plain bullying and hooliganism.

  9. Anne Elly

    Dear Naomi Ragen,

    I love your books!

    Meanwhile, to solve the bus issue, I suggest that the haredi MEN enter from and go to the back. After a short while, the earlier Orthodox rabbinic ruling that in effect “fences around fences” are not required in the marketplace will be duly respected and honoured!

    Sincerely,
    Anne

  10. Oranit Machluf

    dear Mrs. Rage, i would like to express you my sypmpathy and my honor – you are one of the brave women denying the terro of ultraorthodox men in te public busses of jerusalem. A few weeks ago I saw you talking in the report of the journalist Jasmin Caney Mehadrin neged nashim – we – al Jewish women – have to talk about and to arise or voice, if we do not want to be accused in the public busses.
    A week ago I have a trip to Jerusalem. Obviously I used to sit in the back side of autobus feeling more safed there in case of the terrorist attack. But since I saw the report, I decided to use the front side – it is my privilege to set, where I want to. As I did also in Jerusale. Being attacked I woul make a lesson to a Charedi man.Thank you again for arising your voice.

Comments are closed.